Larviciding potency of water and ethanol extracts of Phytolacca dodecandra (L’ Herit) on Anopheles gambiae (Diptera: Culicidae)   

Jared Owiti Yugi1 , Joash Barack Okeyo-Owuor2 , Caleb Awiti Auma1 , Jacqueline India Juma1 , Pamela Were Kogogo4 , John M Vulule3
1. Department of Applied Sciences, Kisumu Polytechnic, P. O. Box 143-40100, Kisumu-Kenya
2. School of Agriculture, Natural resource and Environmental Studies, Rongo University College, P.O. Box 103-40404, Rongo-Kenya
3. Centre for Global Health Research/Kenya Medical research Institute, P. O. Box 1578-4100, Kisumu-Kenya
4. School of Biological and Physical Sciences, Jaramogi Oginga Odinga Technical Univerity, P. O. Box 210-40601, Bondo-Kenya

Author    Correspondence author
Journal of Mosquito Research, 2015, Vol. 5, No. 2   doi: 10.5376/jmr.2015.05.0002
Received: 10 Dec., 2014    Accepted: 23 Feb., 2015    Published: 05 Mar., 2015
© 2015 BioPublisher Publishing Platform
This is an open access article published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Introduction: Plant extracts are an attractive target for search of effective malaria vector control agents. The reason for this is that they present a cost effective, target specific and bio-degradable insecticides. The other reason is that they posses varied phytochemical contents that vectors are unlikely to develop resistance to very soon. In this study, we report on effectiveness of ethanol and water extracts of Phytolacca dodecandra (L’ Herit) against Anopheles gambiae (Diptera: Culicidae) larvae. Methods: Crude ethanol and water extracts of leaves (shoot and midsection) and mature green fruits of P. dodecandra were scrutinized for larvicidal activity against 1st to 4th instar larvae of An. gambiae. Larvicidal bioassays were conducted and effectiveness evaluated using the >80% as per the WHO methods and threshold respectively. ANOVA analyses were performed for statistical justifications of the larvicidal property with P considered significant at p < 0.05. The effects of the extracts were evaluated under laboratory conditions. Result:Ethanol extractswere more potent than water extracts of P. dodecandra as larvicide. The highest mortality (56%) was recorded for L4s for ethanol extracts of mature green fruits of Endod sourced from Eldoret. Water extracts of Neem leaves killed 31% L3s while deltamethrin killed over 80% of all exposed larvae. Conclusion:Ethanol extracts P. dodecandra killed more of the exposed An. gambiae larvae than water extracts. Recorded mortalities due to exposure to the extracts were less than the WHO threshold of >80%. We recommend that additional refinement and tests need to be done before commercial exploitation as a malaria vector larvicide.

Anopheles gambiae; Phytolacca dodecandra; Azadirachta indica; Deltamethrin; Ethanol

Anopheles gambiae Giles s.s. is one of the most prolific malaria vector in Africa (Coetzee et al., 2000). It undergoes a complete life cycle that consists of eggs-larvae-pupae and adults. The eggs hatch to give rise to larvae that develop through four larval instars (L1 -L4). The L4s coil up to become pupae which after a day split dorsally to release adult mosquitoes (Gwadz and Collins, 1996). The larvae occupy temporary aquatic habitats (Minakawa et al., 2004) that are most often small flooded open and sunlight depressions (Adeleke et al., 2008) with mostly clean water.
Management of these aquatic habitats is crucial in the fight against mosquito vectors. Targeting the larvae may be challenging due the fact that the habitats are many and different. However, it has been done by employing source management procedures (Fillinger and Lindsay, 2011) using synthetic larvicides. The problem with this method has been the indiscriminate use of the larvicides and this has led to build up of insecticide pressure resulting in resistance (Devine, 2007) by the target larvae. In addition, the insecticides have been found to be non-selective, non-biodegradable and harmful both to the environment and human (Lee et al., 2001; Cartilla and De la Cruz, 2012).
This has led to intensified search for tools that demonstrate eco-friendliness and target specificity and this has been found with plant extracts otherwise known as botanicals (Chowdhury et al., 2009; Rawani et al., 2009; Chakraborty et al., 2013). Many of these plant extracts have demonstrated mosquito larvicidal effect. For example leaf extracts of Holoptelea integrifolia against Culex vishuni  (Singha et. al., 2012),  root extracts of Tragia involucrata L. (Euphorbiaceae) against Culex quinquefasciatus (Bhattacharya and Chandra, 2014), Nelumbo nucifera against Anopheles stephensi (Ray et al., 2014) and extracts from berries of Phytolacca dodecandra against immature of Filarial Vector Culex quinquefasciatus (Misganaw et al., 2012). Other plant constituents have also demonstrated pupicidal effects (Rawani et al., 2012), knockdown on An. gambiae adults (Yugi et al., 2014), repellency as well as adulticidal (Singha et al., 2011, Chowdhury et al., 2007) toxicity against different mosquito species.  In this study we demonstrate larvicidal effect of ethanol and water extracts of Phytolacca dodecandra (L’ Herit) or Endod on An. gambiae larvae under laboratory conditions.
1 Results
This experiment was conducted for a period of eight months. A total of 84, 240 larvae (L1s, L2s, L3s and L4s) of laboratory cultured An. gambiae mosquitoes were used. It was found that ethanol extracts of Endod plant parts killed the largest percentage of all exposed larval instars compared to water extracts of the same parts.
The highest mortality of exposed larvae was recorded for ethanol extracts of Endod parts sourced from Eldoret compared to ethanol extracts of the same parts of Endod sourced from Nyando. Though ethanol extracts of mature green fruits killed the highest number of exposed larvae (L4s), mortality from exposure to extracts of mature green fruits sourced from Eldoret was almost the same as that of the same parts sourced from Nyando. Ethanol extracts from Neem leaves killed 30% of L3s (Table 1). 



Table 1 Percentage mean mortality of larval stages of An. gambiae exposed to crude ethanol extracts of Endod parts


The L1s were the most sensitive to water extracts of Endod parts with the highest number of mortality being observed for both extracts of Endod leaves of the shoot sourced from Eldoret and Nyando. L3s were more sensitive to water extracts of Neem leaves (Table 2). Preparations of deltamethrin killed over 80% of all exposed larval instars.



Table 2 Percentage mean mortality of larval stages of An. gambiae from exposure to crude water extracts of parts of Endod


2 Discussions
Inability to mount an effective control of mosquito borne diseases remains a big challenge even today. Though many methods are available for use to protect against mosquito bites, there is room for further advice and even tools to control the menace. The best approach to reduce mosquito population is to employ cost-effective, biodegradable natural insecticides from botanicals. This is because aside from being readily available and effective, their chemical components are varied and therefore the target insects might never develop resistance to their use (Miresmailli et al., 2006).
In this study it was observed that extracts of both mature green fruits and leaves of Endod were potent against larval stages of An gambiae though percent mortality did not meet the WHO threshold. The fourth larval instars were more sensitive to ethanol extracts from mature green fruits of Endod that resulted in over 55% deaths. This observation was consistent with that of essential oils of Plectranthus glandulosus and Callistemon rigidus extracted from their Leaves and used against L4s of Ae. aegypti, An. gambiae and Cx. Quinquefasciatus (Pierre et al., 2014) and Anacardium occidentale, Afromomum melegueta, Garcina kola and Citrus sinensis against the developmental stages of mosquito, An. gambiae Giles (Ileke et al., 2014).
Ethanol extracts of all parts of Endod were more potent than water extracts of similar parts. This demonstrated that the type of solvent used in the extraction of the phytochemical determined the potency of the extracted bioactive botanicals (Anupam et al., 2012). Ethanol is less polar (polarity index of 0.1) than water (polarity index of 10.2).  It extracted biochemicals with lower molecular weight as compared to those extracted by water. Biochemicals of high molecular weights such as proteins, glycans are of low potency and this explains the difference in potency between ethanol and water extracts. 
Solvent types were also seen influencing larvicidal potency of Solanum xanthocarpum (Mohan et al., 2006), Euphorbia tirucalli (Singh et al., 2007), Eucalyptus globules (Maurya et al., 2007; Singh et al., 2007), Citrullus colocynthis (Sakthivadivel et al., 2008), Azadirechta indica (Mgbemena et al., 2010) and Solanum nigrum (Raghavendra et al., 2009). It is probable that ethanol extracts were superior to water extracts of the parts of Endod by causing the highest mortality of the exposed larvae by blocking more efficiently the spiracles through which the larvae breathe (Kaufmann and Briegel, 2004). This then leads to asphyxiation and subsequent death (Ileke and Oni, 2011; Ileke and Olotuah, 2012) of the larvae.
Ethanol extracts of bioactive phytochemicals from Endod parts sourced from Eldoret were more potent than ethanol extracts of the same parts sourced from Nyando. This showed that the geography of the source of the plants played a role in the concentration and distribution of phytochemical in the plant. This finding was similar to an earlier one that found variation in phytochemical activity from Endod (Were, 2008), Citrus sp, Ocimum sanctum and Azadirechta indica (Mgbemena et al., 2010) and Jatropha sp (Sakthivadivel and Daniel, 2008) based on geographical source (Anupam et al., 2012).
This study concludes that the phytoextracts from Endodhas activity on all larval instars of An. gambiae. However, before commercial exploitation there is a need for the components of the larvicidal extracts to be isolated, processed further and exposed to further tests under laboratory and field conditions.
3 Materials and methods
3.1 Study area, experimental mosquitoes and study design
Eggs used for the experiments were of An. gambiae mosquitoes kept at the insectary of the Entomological laboratory at the Centre for Global Health Research/Kenya Medical Research Institute (CGHR/KEMRI) and reared following standard techniques (Das et al., 2007), following procedures and conditions described in Yugi et al., (2014). A completely randomized informal ‘after-only with control’ experimental design (Kothari 2004) was used to investigate the ovicidal effect of crude ethanol and water extracts of Endod on An. gambiae mosquito larvae.
3.2 Plant materials
Fresh leaves (shoot and midsection) and mature green fruits of Phytolacca dodecandra (Endod) were collected from the field near Moi Girls High School, Eldoret [+0.518829oN, 35.284927oE] and Kanyagwal, Nyando [-0.250393oN, 34.870190oE]. Fresh leaves of Azadirachta indica (Neem) collected from Kanyagwal, Nyando [-0.250393oN, 34.870190oE]. The plant parts were collected on 3rd and 4th May 2012, thereafter identified by Mr. Patrick Mutiso of the School of Biological Sciences, University of Nairobi and voucher specimen number JOY2012/001 for P. dodecandra and JOY2012/002 for A. indica deposited in the herbarium at the School.
3.3 Plant extract and deltamethrin preparation
Leaves (shoot and midsection) and mature green fruits of Endod and the leaves of Neem were used to obtain plant extracts. Ethanol and water extracts were obtained from the plant parts, freeze dried, preserved and serially diluted as described elsewhere (Yugi et al., 2014). Deltamethrin was obtained and similarly prepared as described elsewhere (Yugi et al., 2014).
3.4 Larvicidal bioassays
Larvicidal activities were conducted in accordance to the WHO method (WHO, 1996). Batches of twenty freshly hatched or moulted larvae (1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th instars) of An. gambiae were transferred by means of the dropper to plastic containers measuring 6 cm mouth and 5.7 cm base diameter by 3.5 cm height arranged in sets according to the concentrations of the extracts used. Each set was made up of three plastic containers and each container received approximately 33 millilitres of a particular concentration of treated harvested rain aqueous. Appropriate volume of stock solutions of each treatment of crude ethanol and aqueous extracts were added to 100 ml aqueous in the glass beakers and then serially diluted to obtain 40, 20, 10, 5 and 2.5mg/100mls of the crude extracts. Three replicates were set up for each concentration including two positive (Neem and deltamethrin) and one negative control (untreated harvested rain aqueous).
The exposed larval stages of An. gambiae were left to stay in the treatments on experimental tables overnight. Mortality rate were registered after 24 hour exposure period. Standard WHO procedures were used to assess the level of toxicity (larvicidal effectiveness) at a mortality rate of > 80% (WHO, 2005). All exposed larvae were collected in a pail of hot aqueous at the end of the experiments and disposed off in a septic tank.
3.5 Data analysis
Data obtained from the bioassays was entered in excel spreadsheets and the relationship between larvicidal effect of the extracts with part of Endod plant used and concentration determined using descriptive statistics. One way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine the level of significance of the effects of treatments on larvae mortality. All statistical analysis was performed using SAS statistical package version 20. 
Authors’ contributions
YJO conceived the idea, sourced for funds, conducted the experiments and wrote the manuscript. YJO and O-OJB designed the experiments and sourced for funds. O-OJB, WKP and VJM supervised and guided the experiments. YJO, ACA and JJI extracted phytochemicals from the plants and sourced for wild An. gambiae mosquitoes. All authors read and corrected the manuscript.
Competing interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
We thank Richard Amito and Charles Owaga for processing and culturing the experimental mosquitoes, Kisumu Polytechnic for equipments for the extractions of the phytochemicals from Endod and Neem plants, Centre for Global Health Research/Kenya Medical Research Institute (CGHR/KEMRI) for laboratory space, mosquitoes and equipments for conducting the experiments, VIRED International for providing transportation and logistics for sourcing for Endod and Neem. This project was funded by the National Commission for Science Technology and Innovation (NACOSTI).
Adeleke M.A., Mafian C.F., Idowu A.B., Adekunle, M.F., and Sam-Wobo, S.O., 2008, Mosquito larval habitats and public health implications in Abeokuta, Ogun State, Nigeria. Tanzania Journal of Health Research, 10(2): 103
Anupam G., Nandita C., and Goutam C., 2012, Plant extracts as potential mosquito larvicides. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 135: 581-598
Bhattacharya K., and Chandra G., 2014, Phagodeterrence, larvicidal and oviposition deterrence activity of Tragia involucrata L. (Euphorbiaceae) root extractives against vector of lymphatic filariasis Culex quinquefasciatus (Diptera: Culicidae), Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Diseases, 4(Suppl 1): S226-S232
Cartilla P., and De la Cruz J., 2012, Termiticidal Potential of Stachytarpheta Jamaicensis (L.) Vahl, 1: 1-5
Chakraborty S., Singha S., Bhattacharya K., and Chandra G., 2013, Control of human filarial vector, Culex quinquefasciatus Say 1823 (Diptera: Culicidae) through bioactive fraction of Cayratia trifolia leaf, Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Biomedicine, 3(12): 980-984
Chowdhury N., Bhattacharjee I., Laskar S., and Chandra G., 2007, Efficacy of Solanum villosum Mill. (Solanaceae: Solanales) as a biocontrol agent against fourth instar larvae of Culex quinquefasciatus Say, Turkish Journal of Zoology, 31(4): 365-370
Chowdhury N., Chatterjee S.K., Laskar S., and Chandra G., 2009, Larvicidal activity of Solanum villosum Mill (Solanaceae: Solanales) leaves to Anopheles subpictus Grassi (Diptera: Culicidae) with effect on non- target Chironomus circumdatus Kieffer (Diptera: Chironomidae), Journal of Pesticide Science, 82: 13-18
Das N.G., Goswami D., and Rabha B., 2007, Preliminary evaluation of mosquito larvicidal efficacy of plant extracts. Journal of Vector Borne Diseases, 44: 145-148
Devine G.J., and Furlong M.J., 2007, Insecticide use: Contexts and ecological consequences, Agriculture and Human Values, 24:281-306
Fillinger U., and Lindsay S.W., 2011, Larval source management for malaria control in Africa: myths and reality. Malaria Journal, 10: 353
Gwadz R., and Collins F.H., 1996, Anopheline mosquitoes and the agents they transmit. In: Beaty, B.J., and Marquardt, W.T., Eds. Biology of disease vectors. University Press of Colorado, USA, pp. 73-84
Ileke K.D., and Olotuah O.F., 2012, Bioactivity Anacardium occidentale (L) and Allium sativum (L) powders and oilExtracts against cowpea Bruchid, Callosobruchus maculatus (Fab.) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), InternationalJournal of Biology, 4(1): 8-13
Ileke K.D., and Oni M.O., 2011, Toxicity of some plant powders to maize weevil, Sitophilus zeamais (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) on stored wheat grains, African Journal of Agricultural Research, 6(13): 3043-3048
Ileke K.D., Afolabi O. J., Ogungbite, O.C., Olayinka-Olagunju, J.O., and Akanbi, O.M., 2014, Mosquitocidal activity of Anacardium occidentale, Afromomum melegueta, Garcina kola and Citrus sinensis against the developmental stages of mosquito, Anopheles gambiae Giles. Journal of Mosquito Research, 4(3): 21-26
Kaufmann C., and Briegel H., 2004, Flight performance of the malaria vectors Anopheles gambiae and Anopheles atroparous (CPDF), Journal of Vector Ecology, 29(1): 140-153
Kothari C.R., 2004, Research design: research methodology, methods and techniques. 2nd edition. New Age International Publishers, New Delhi, India
Lee S.E., Kim J., and Lee S., 2001, Insecticide resistance in increasing interest, Agriculture and Chemical Biotechnology, 44: 105–112
Maurya P., Mohan L., Sharma P., Batabyal L., and Srivastava C.N., 2007, Larvicidal ef?cacy of Aloe barbadensis and Cannabis sativa against the malaria vector Anopheles stephensi (Diptera: Culicidae). Entomological Research, 37:153-156
Mgbemena I.C., 2010, Comparative evaluation of larvicidal potentials of three plant extracts on Aedes aegypti. Journal of American Science,6:435- 440
Minakawa N., Sonye, G., Mogi M., and Yan G., 2004, Habitat characteristics of Anopheles gambiae s.s. larvae in a Kenyan highland. Medical and Veterinary Entomology, 18: 301-305
Miresmailli S., Bradbury R., and Isman M.B., 2006, Comparative toxicity of Rosmarinus officinalis L. essential oil and blends of its major constituents against Tetranychus urticae Koch (Acari: Tetranychidae) on two different host plants. Pest Management Science, 62: 366–371
Misganaw, N., Moges, S., Tadele, M., Tesera, M., Temesgen T., and Raja N., 2012, Evaluation of Multi Potential Bioactive Endod, Phytolacca dodecandra (L’ Herit) Berries Extracts against Immature Filarial Vector Culex quinquefasciatus Say (Diptera: Culicidae). Research Journal of Environmental and Earth Sciences, 4(7): 697-703
Mohan L., Sharma P., and Shrivastava C.N., 2006, Evaluation of Solanum xanthocarpumextracts as a synergist for cypermethrin againstlarvae of filarial vector Culex quinquefasciatus (Say). Entomological Research, 36:220-225
Pierre D.Y.S., Okechukwu,  E.C., Lame, Y., and Nchiwan, N.E., 2014, Larvicidal and Pupicidal Activities of Plectranthus glandulosus and Callistemon rigidus Leaf Essential Oils against Three Mosquito Species. Journal of Mosquito Research, 4(2): 5-14
Raghavendra K., Singh S.P., Subbarao S.K., and Dash A.P., 2009, Laboratory studies on mosquito larvicidal efficacy of aqueous & hexane extracts of dried fruit of Solanum nigrum Linn. Indian Journal of Medical Resources,130:74-77
Rawani A., Ghosh A., Laskar S., and Chandra G., 2012, Aliphatic amide from seeds of Carica papaya as mosquito larvicide, pupicide, adulticide, repellent and smoke toxicant, Journal of Mosquito Research, 2(2) doi:10.5376 /jmr.2012.02.0002
Rawani A., Mallick H.K., Ghosh A., and Chandra G., 2009, Larvicidal activities of three plants against filarial vector Culex quinquefasciatus Say (Diptera: Culicidae), Parasitology Research, 105(5): 1411-1417
Ray, A.S., Bhattacharya, K., Singh, A., and Chandra, G., 2014, Larvicidal Activity of Nelumbo nucifera Gaertn. (Nymphaeaceae) against Anopheles stephensi (Liston 1901) and its Effect on Non-target Organisms. Journal of mosquito research, 4(10): 1-7
Sakthivadivel M., and Daniel T., 2008, Evaluation of certain insecticidal plants for the control of vector mosquitoes viz. Culex quinquefasciatus, Anopheles stephensi and Aedes aegypti. Application of Entomological Zoology, 43:57- 63
Singh R.K., Dhiman R.C., and Mittal P.K., 2007, Studies on mosquito larvicidal properties of Eucalyptus citriodora Hook (family Myrtaceae). Journal of Communicable Diseases, 39:233-236
Singha S., Adhikari U., and Chandra G., 2011, Smoke repellency and mosquito larvicidal potentiality of Mesua ferra L. leaf extract against filarial vector Culex quinquefasciatus Say, Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Biomedicine, 1(1): S119-S123
Singha S., Adhikari U., Ghosh A., and Chandra G., 2012, Mosquito Larvicidal Potentiality of Holoptelea integrifolia Leaf Extract against Japanese Encephalitis Vector, Culex vishuni Group, Journal of Mosquito Research, 2(4): 25-31
Were P.K., 2008, Efficacy of Phytolacca dodecandra on Anopheles gambiae mosquito larvae. A PhD thesis submitted to the School of Environmental Studies, Moi University, Supervisor: Okeyo-Owuor, J.B., pp. 78-143
WHO 1996, Report of the WHO informal Consultation on the Evaluation and Testing of Insecticides, Geneva. 37
WHO 2005, Guidelines for laboratory and field testing of mosquito larvicides. World Health Organization communicable disease control, prevention and eradication who pesticide evaluation scheme. WHO/CDS/WHOPES /GCDPP/2005, 13
Yugi J.O., Okeyo-Owour J.B., Atieli F.2, Amito R., and Vulule J.M., 2014, Knockdown effect of crude ethanol extracts of Phytolacca dodecandra on Anopheles gambiae adults. Journal of Mosquito Research, 4 (18): 1-7
Journal of Mosquito Research
• Volume 5
View Options
. PDF(440KB)
. FPDF(win)
. Online fPDF
Associated material
. Readers' comments
Other articles by authors
. Jared Yugi
. Joash Okeyo-Owuor
. Caleb Auma
. Jacqueline Juma
. Pamela Kogogo
. John Vulule
Related articles
. Anopheles gambiae
. Phytolacca dodecandra
. Azadirachta indica
. Deltamethrin
. Ethanol
. Email to a friend
. Post a comment